Peter Poggione

When the Montana Legislature passed Senate Bill 542, it built into the bill a big fat middle finger to those of us who are fortunate enough to have second homes here. Never did the elected officials consider that all people who own second homes are not multi-millionaires or billionaires who can absorb property taxes that are increasing by a factor of two to three.

Many of us are regular middle-class people who worked hard to achieve the dream of a summer home in a place as incredible as Montana. We planned, we saved, we sacrificed, and we busted our butts to make it happen. And we played by the rules.

Now, the rules are changing, and we very well could be priced out, only to be replaced by the ultra-rich of the world who can afford previously unimaginable tax hikes.

When my family built a home in Bigfork 14 years ago, we did so based on certain realities that are now being thrown by the wayside to make room for vote-garnering laws that are not only unfair, but seem downright wrong - not to mention borderline illegal since the tax burden has, according to a recent article in the Beacon, “shifted away from some class members to other class members within the same class.”

How anyone can justify me paying twice as much property tax as the neighbors on both sides of me is unfathomable.

Whether we spend seven months a year in Montana, or seven weeks, or even seven minutes, it should not be a basis for us to treated differently than those who live here year round. In fact, an argument could be made that we should pay lower property taxes because we are not putting pressure on the school districts, we are not putting wear and tear on the roads, we are not placing calls for emergency services, and we are simply not getting as much out of our property taxes as everyone else is. But that’s okay. We don’t mind, because when we are in Montana, it is our home too, and homes need to be maintained.

That is why we support local businesses. We support local charities. We support local artists. And, even though we don’t get to vote, we support the local politicians. We are as much part of the fabric of the community as anyone else and hope and expected to be treated as such.

When my great, great grandfather emigrated from Indianapolis to Billings in April of 1902 to raise sheep, he was welcomed with open arms. He became a fixture in the community and served two terms in the state Legislature. I would like to think he would not be in support of this type of legislation then, or now.

Please put a kibosh on Senate Bill 542 for the sake of fairness. Don’t push good people who care about Montana - and have invested in Montana - out.  If you want to balance the state’s budget, I suggest sales tax as a better, more equitable, solution.

Peter Poggione lives in Bigfork